Bio(Freakin')Shock!

While CoD4 was probably the best online multiplayer shooter. Bioshock was clearly one of the best games ever. The immersiveness of the story, the weaponry and Tonics and such. I had a blast playing it. While the replay value isn't exactly high It was one of those games I actually enjoyed working my way through it. Then went through again for the diarys and tonic I missed first play through.

Easily a 10/10 and I'm glad it won Spike Tv's game of the year it deserved it.

I will give you that, I only played through it once because I just rented it and spent a weekend beating it...

It was one of the best stories in a game in a VERY long while though...

I loved Bioshock. The only thing that drove me nuts was you couldn't go back and buy all the plasmids you missed after you finished the game, and the fact that the Bid Daddy helmet was annoying. Seriously though, it was probably the best campaign shooter I've ever played, though it looks like Fallout 3 may in fact be better.

Bioshock is in my opinion the greatest shooter to ever come out, I still prefer Rock Band over it though.